Commercial Audit

For service pages, city pages and listings, against the live top 5: what the buyer checks before ordering and whether your page answers it concretely, where it stops selling, and which of your claims have proof next to them.

Topical MapWhat your site covers Commercial AuditWhat the buyer checks
1
What keyword are you selling for?We pull the live top 5 — directories included, if that’s who ranks.
2
Which page of yours competes?A published URL of the page you sell from.
Compare against specific pages instead of the live top Optional, 2–10
Empty = the live top 5. Filled in = a private benchmark against pages you choose; the “commercial SERP” verdict then describes your list, not Google’s.
35 credits
Commercial Audit
1What the buyer checksmust-have, everyone-has, nobody-has

Two coordinate systems on one page. The buyer tree lists what someone evaluates before ordering — timeline, deliverables, pricing model, who does the work, platform segments. The SERP shows what the top already says. Where they agree it's a must-have; what only the SERP repeats is optional consensus; what neither covers is your whitespace. Concreteness is checked per branch: tools, formats, numbers — present or not. No density, no score.

3Claims, proof, names and datesevidence

Every "expert", "leading", "years of experience" is a claim. We look for a passage on the same page that actually entails it — a case with numbers, a named process, a date. Unsupported claims are listed, not scored. Alongside: whether your team has names and roles, whether the page carries time markers, and whether the first screen states the offer, a price anchor, a fact and an action.

Proof content
Who stands behind it
Time markers
First screen first 20% of the text
CTA ladder

Parity with the top

No worse on the table: blocks, schema depth, card attributes — each weighted by how many of the ranking pages have it. This used to be the whole report; now it's the floor, not the goal.

Feature matrixsorted by how many of the top have it

A feature 4 of 5 competitors share is table stakes; a feature only you have is your edge.

Topic relevanceis your page inside the semantic field of this SERP?

Zones are calibrated on the top's own passages — never fixed thresholds.

What this audit can't moveoff-page weights from surveys

This tool measures your page. For the local pack, most of the weight sits off the page — and for AI answers the balance flips back toward on-page. Both columns below are survey weights, not our invention.

LLM answers to commercial queries are decided elsewhere. Assistants rarely cite the vendor’s own site; for “which X should I pick” prompts they lean on third-party listicles. The check below is the only honest one this page can run; the rest belongs to AI Visibility.
Local Pack / Maps Whitespark Local Search Ranking Factors 2026
Google Business Profile
32%
Reviews
20%
On-page this audit
~19%
Behavioral
9%
AI Overviews / AI Mode same survey, AI-visibility weighting
On-page this audit
~24%
Google Business Profile
~12%

For being cited in AI answers, on-page rises to the top slot — the work this audit points at weighs roughly twice what it does in Maps.

What it checks

What the buyer checks

Timeline, pricing model, who does the work, deliverables: each branch is marked must-have, optional or nobody-has-it against the top 5, with whether your answer is concrete (a number, a format, a name) or only words.

Where the page stops selling

Each paragraph is compared with the commercial and the informational pages of this same top and marked by the one it sits closer to. Strike paragraphs out and watch the balance move: no credits, no rewrite pushed.

Which claims have proof

“Expert”, “leading”, “15 years”: each claim is checked for a passage on the page that backs it, such as a case with numbers, a named process or a date. Unsupported claims are listed, not scored.

What the report looks like

What buyers in this SERP expect and whether you answer it, where the page stops selling, and which claims stand without proof.

What we don’t do

Clear limits, so you know what the audit judges and what it leaves to you.

Invent scores or weights

No page score or readiness percentage. A feature weighs as much as the share of the top 5 that has it; claims are a list with a count, each traceable to the SERP or your page.

Promise rankings or AI answers

For local queries most of the weight sits in your Business Profile and reviews, off the page. For “which provider” prompts, assistants lean on listicles; whether they cite you is in AI Visibility.

Ask you to rewrite boilerplate

“Call us today” may read like everyone else’s, and that’s fine. Uniqueness is measured only on proof (cases, numbers, process), never as a keyword-density percentage.

Score your design

No screenshot beauty contest. Filters, calculators and maps count as user value the top also offers, and layout is read as where content sits, not how polished it looks.